|
People are losing
weight eating bacon and eggs-others
by eating only grapefruit or
cabbage. Some claim to lose
weight in their sleep or by
breathing differently. Are these
diets safe and based on scientific
research? Or are marketing teams
using isolated testimonials
to dazzle the public with a
diet's reputed
success?
The following
summarizes some of the most
popular types of diets on the
market today, benefits and disadvantages
whether the plan can be maintained
for life, since that is the
only way to change-a lifestyle
change.
High
Protein Plans:
Overview: Best-sellers
such as Dr. Adkins New Diet
Revolution, Neander-Thin: Eat
Like a Caveman to Achieve a
Lean, strong, Healthy Body,
and Sugar Busters!: Cut
Sugar to Trim Fat claim
that dieters can lose all the
weight they want by eliminating
carbohydrates and sugar from
their diets. With
the lure of eating "forbidden
foods," authors charge
that processed carbohydrates
and insulin, not excess calories,
are responsible for obesity
in the United States. The low-carb,
high-protein plans generally
consist of between 1,200-1,800
calories. This calorie range
would result in a weight loss
no matter what combination of
foods (carbohydrate, protein
and fat) was employed.
Advantages:
Users seem to gravitate to the
plans' simplicity and seemingly
attractive menues (eat meat,
bacon, eggs, and butter). By
eliminating carbohydrates and
sugar from the diet, a significant
number of calories are also
eliminated.
Disadvantages:
The downside to these plans
is their reliance on protein.
High-protein diets can put the
body into a state of ketosis,
causing headaches, bad breath,
nausea, and carbohydrate cravings
due to depleted glycogen stores.
These diets are too high in
saturated fats and too low in
fruits, whole grains, calcium
and fiber.
Long-Term Success:
Information from the National
Weight Control Registry indicates
that high-protein, low-carbohydrate
diets are not maintained for
life. After the initial weight
loss, the dieter eventually
rebounds if carbohydrates are
reintroduced into the diet.
Low-Fat
Plans:
Overview: Contrary to
the wash of high-protein diets,
plans such as Dr. Dean Ornish's
Eat more, Weigh Less and
Robert Pritikin's The Pritikin
Weight Loss Breakthrough: Five
Easy Steps to Outsmart Your
Fat Instinct recommend a
diet very low in fat (approximately
10 percent of the total calories)
and high in carbohydrates with
heavy focus on vegetarian choices.
The basic premise for these
plans is that calories from
fat cause one to become fat.
Advantages:
The benefit to this type of
diet is that a small percentage
of the population would feel
good with very low fat and high
carbohydrates. The recommendation
to choose lean cuts of meats
over higher-fat varieties si
sound advice and helps to lower
caloric intake, which may reduce
the risk of coronary heart disease.
Disadvantages:
Studies by the National Weight
Control Registry indicate that
the majority of those who have
lost weight and kept if off
were more successful with a
diet comprised of 55 percent
carbohydrate, 20 percent protein
and 25 percent fat. This type
of diet encourages minimal fat
and protein intake.
Long-term Success:
Dietary fat is important to
success for a number of reasons
including the transportation
of vitamins, satiety (feeling
full) and the simple pleasure
of consuming some food with
some fat content. The bottom
line to any diet plan relates
to the Law of Thermodynamics:
When energy (calories) in exceeds
energy (calories) out, weight
gain results. When energy out
exceeds energy in, weight loss
is the result.
Fasting
Plans:
Overview: Plans like
the Cabbage Soup Diet and
Grapfruit Diet boast
staggering
weight loss (as much as 20 lbs
in seven days) and these are
extremely restricting and potentially
dangerous methods. Because the
plans often consist of less
than 1,000 calories a day, rapid
weight loss occurs.
Advantages:
Other than rapid weight loss,
there are no advantages to this
type of plan.
Disadvantages:
The downside to such an extreme
approach to this method is weight
loss is temporary. Weight loss
either represents water weight
or lean body tissue. Furthermore,
many dieters report nausea,
light-headedness and gas as
common side effects of the plan.
Long-term Success:
Lifestyle changes regarding
healthy eating and exercise
are not addressed in this type
of plan. Weight rebound is inevitable.
Thousands of diet
plans add up to a $40-billion-a-year
weight-loss industry. The public
wants to get thin and the entrepreneur
wants to get fat with profits.
Anyone can become a weight-loss
guru with a hot marketing team,
a few choice testimonials and
a smooth presentation. However,
while the weight-loss industry
continues to grow, obesity has
reached epidemic proportions.
The diet plans
outlined above are nothing more
than low-calorie nutrition plans
disguised by clever marketing
gimmicks,. Scientific-sounding
"facts" and hocus-pocus
"research" can dazzle
and confuse the average consumer.
Diet-plan marketers go to great
lengths to explain how their
diet can work for everyone,
or claim that it is carbohydrate
intake (or any other dieters
"enemy of the month")
that is the culprit. However,
the bottom line is that a calorie
deficit (more calories burned
than consumed) causes weight
loss. The average American consumes
300 more calories than he/she
did 30 years ago. He/she also
burns 260 less calories each
day due to increased automation,
technology and sedentary occupations.
Increased caloric intake and
decreased caloric expenditure
means that the waistline of
America (and the world) is growing
at an alarming rate.
While fad diets
may initially offer rapid weight
loss, the result is too often
temporary, leaving the dieter
defeated, angry and often with
a few extra pounds just for
good measure. The problem with
fad diets is that they are just
that-fads. Every author claims
to have the seceret plan that
will lead to weight loss. However,
conflicting information and
a 98-percent failure rate leaves
the consumer confused and in
search of the next "miracle"
plan. The only key to long-term
weight loss is adopting a healthy
lifestyle for life.
HARDCORE
|